Codey Steele has the perfect prank for his stepsisters, Chloe Cherry and Haley Reed. While the girls are getting dressed in Halloween costumes for trick or treat, they start getting creepy texts from Momo. Chloe gets the first text, but Momo is soon seen following both girls around the house. Chloe gets another text indicating that Momo can see them. The next text tells the girls to find their brother because he can protect them. They wind up in bed together, calling for Codey. They ask him to sleep with them, but only if they're naked. At first the girls say no, but Codey calls their bluff and they call him back so they can strip for him.
Since the girls have stripped, Codey says he'll take his underwear off, too. They're grossed out that Codey has a boner, but he points out that Chloe is his stepsister and Haley is adopted so they should do something about it. The girls want him to stay with them, so they get on their bellies and suck Codey's cock. Codey enjoys the double BJ, but what he really wants is to fuck those two hot girls at once. He doesn't even need to say something before Haley and Chloe turn around and present themselves to him so he can fuck first Haley and then Chloe doggy style.
When Codey lays down in the bed, the girls each mount him in reverse cowgirl. Chloe takes Codey's mouth, while Haley gets to ride his fuck stick. The girls roll onto their backs, once again side by side, so Codey can have his choice of their pussy buffet. He starts with Haley, but finishes with Chloe as he fills her twat all the way up with a creampie. The girls are happy to be protected by Codey since now he has to keep up his end of the deal and stay the night.