Jay Romero gets to decide his new stepsister from two candidates: Lexi Lore and Chanel Camryn. They begin the day in the pool, where Chanel comes on strong. Lexi goes right for her timeout card, sending Chanel away before she can totally seduce Jay. Taking the hint, Jay goes all in to get with Lexi ASAP.

They're interrupted by Chanel, who announces that she's cold and it's her turn for a timeout. Within moments she's snuggled with Jay on a couch, her hand rubbing his hardon beneath a blanket. Tit for tat, Lexi interrupts them and says their time is up and it's time to move on to the next activity. Before Chanel can move them on to their next activity Lexi suggests Jay take his shirt off. In return, Chanel takes her whole dress off, which leads Lexi to pop her own tits out. Soon the girls are fighting over Jay right up until he suggests they work as a team.

Lexi can do that. She saunters over to Chanel, where they make out and then push Jay onto the bed so they can blow him together. Their threesome kicks off with Chanel riding Jay's face and Lexi cowgirl on his dick. Chanel gets her own stiffie ride when the girls switch spots. On her knees, Lexi takes a doggy style pussy pounding while she eats Chanel out. Chanel scoots forward so Lexi can sit on her face as Jay dicks her down until he pulls out to pop. The girls share their cummy treat, but in the end Jay decides he connected better with Lexi.